Why Tech Hiring Needs Both AI and Expert Tech Recruiters

Explaining recursion to a robot. Again.

The challenge: Too many applicants, not enough quality. With modern job listings receiving upwards of 200 resumes, and hot jobs often 400+, AI-driven Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) filter resumes based on keywords and algorithms — often screening out 88% of candidates before a human even looks. That sounds efficient — but it also means qualified professionals with less AI-savvy résumés get overlooked. And yes, we are all using AI to do the heavy lifting, but applicants are not putting in enough cultural information about their experiences and desires to add any relevance to the screening process. In fact, applicants have been advised for decades not to list what they want on their resumes, and to keep it as broad as possible.   So now we have a pile of skills based candidates without context.

An experienced technical recruiter, in your company’s niche, understands context – such as who competes with you, what type of corporate culture would fit, do the benefits stack up, career path etc.  There is so much more to finding your next great hire than screening out candidates who are not an obvious fit and then interviewing the remainder.

ATS boosts speed — but not always substance

Yes:

• ATS can reduce hiring cycles by up to 60%, speed time-to-hire, and boost recruiter efficiency.

• But:

• Only 4–6% of applicants ever progress to interviews — meaning thousands get filtered out prematurely

• Further, 63% of candidates report frustration and a lack of personalization, with 54% abandoning processes due to poor engagement.

  
  

AI isn’t objective — it reflects its creators. AI screening can reduce some human biases, but it can also introduce algorithmic bias, penalizing talented candidates for minor resume quirks or unconventional backgrounds.

 How smartsourcers Uses AI — and Keeps the Heart in Hiring

1. Smart automation upfront

   
   

   We deploy AI-powered ATS and filters to handle the high-volume deluge — identifying resumes that match core requirements.

   
   

2. Experienced recruiter "triage" next

   
   

   Each AI-selected resume is reviewed by seasoned tech recruiters who conduct live screenings — digging into alignment, culture, communication, and nuanced potential.

   
   

3. Talent curation and qualification

   
   

   We deliver curated shortlists of fully vetted candidates, backed by interviews, insight into strengths, and a clear fit beyond keywords

   .

 Real Numbers: Why This Matters

• 88% of applicants filtered out by AI

• Only 4–6% advance to interviews

• 63% of candidates frustrated by impersonal ATS systems

• 54% would apply elsewhere due to lack of engagement

• AI can’t screen for business drivers and applicants’ reasons for their job search

  
  

By adding a human review, throughout the process, we uncover top talent that pure AI screening would miss — while keeping volumes efficient.

What This Means for You

Without Expert Headhunters	With AI + Expert Recruiting
Overlooked talent due to ATS keyword bias	High-fit candidates identified by context-aware screeners
Time wasted on unqualified resumes	Only quality candidates move forward
Risk of poor hire fit	Better hire retention, stronger performance
Mixed hiring feedback and candidate experience	Personalized outreach leaves positive brand impression

Client Impact

Our hybrid model helps clients:

• Improve shortlist-to-hire ratios — only 3–4 high-value candidates presented per role

• Reduce turnover costs — better matching means fewer bad hires

• Enhance employer brand — respectful, personalized candidate experience boosts reputation

• We diplomatically notify every unsuccessful candidate on your behalf

• We have a no-strings guarantee on every placement

  
  

Final Takeaway: AI + Headhunters = Hiring Gold

Purely bot-driven recruitment is fast — but often shallow. Human-led hiring is insightful — but time-consuming. When combined, you get the speed of AI and the nuance of expertise, delivering quality hires, faster.

Let’s talk about how smartsourcers can tailor this approach for your tech team.  You can reach us on the contact page form, or by emailing us:  support@smartsourcers.com